OUTniagara
  • Menu Canvas
    • Our Community
      • Membership – Join us!
      • Community Groups and Organizations
      • OUTfriends Business & Services Directory
      • Humans of OUTniagara
      • 2SLGBTQ+ Community Fund
    • About Us
      • Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
      • Meet Our Staff
      • Contact Us
    • Resources
      • Indigenous Solidarity Resources
      • Beyond the Rainbow Resource Syllabus
      • OUT IN Niagara Education Resources
    • DONATE
    • Informed, Inclusive, Indivisible: Collectively Advancing 2SLGBTQ+ Equality in Niagara+
    • Sidebar
Uniting Niagara's Sexual and Gender Diverse Community.
OUTniagara
  • OUR COMMUNITY
    • Membership – Join Us!
    • Community Groups and Organizations
    • Humans of OUTniagara
    • Indigenous Solidarity Resources
  • ABOUT US
    • Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
    • Meet Our Staff
    • Annual Reports
    • Contact Us
  • Resources
    • Indigenous Solidarity Resources
    • Beyond the Rainbow Resource Syllabus
    • OUT IN Niagara Education Resources
  • Donate
  • 2SLGBTQ+ Community Fund
  • Informed, Inclusive, Indivisible: Collectively Advancing 2SLGBTQ+ Equality in Niagara+
    • Community Strengths & Needs Assessment

Bill C-150: attitudes versus legislation

Homepage OUT With It 2SLGBTQ+ History Bill C-150: attitudes versus legislation

Bill C-150: attitudes versus legislation

Jenn Wallace
October 15, 2019
2SLGBTQ+ History

Bill C-150: attitudes versus legislation

 
By Dennis Yeo, Niagara community member
 

A former colleague, also gay and of a very similar vintage to my own, once remarked, “You can legislate behaviour, but you can’t legislate attitudes.” Perhaps that simple idea plays a significant role in our community’s lack of passion about our collective history. We have been led to believe, contrary to what we now realize, that when Bill C-150 passed in 1969 we were decriminalized and safer from prosecution and persecution than we actually are. And so the significance of specific events in the struggle over the last 50 years lose gravitas as those of us who lived it now measure the time since in decades, and those who came after never felt the urge to know much more about it than the snippets delivered by the media during Pride Months.

In an article printed in The Globe and Mail in 2009, Senator Laurier LaPierre rightly gives credit to Pierre Trudeau for Bill C-150, but Trudeau’s executive assistant, Tim Porteous, attributes the legislation not only to his boss’ conception of a “just society” but also to his “sense of mischief” and the pleasure he took in provoking people. For me, this changed the context, so I dug a little deeper into the events of that time in 1968-69.

Trudeau was still Justice Minister in early 1968 when the original Bill C-195 was drafted and seems to have had a genuine sense of right and wrong and a dedication to righting the wrongs. It was an omnibus bill that referenced a variety of matters, including abortion and gun control, but it was the issue of homosexuality that most riled the masses and engendered fierce debate and fear-mongering in and around the House of Commons.

Interestingly, by the time the revised bill, now C-150, came to the House for a vote, Trudeau had been elected Prime Minister and it was left to the new Justice Minister John Turner who “somewhat reluctantly” re-introduced the bill in December that year. He declined to be interviewed by The Globe and Mail for that 2009 article but seemed at the time, January ’69, to assume the role of just the messenger (who didn’t wish to be shot), giving all credit for the legislation to Trudeau. He is quoted as telling the House of Commons that it was Trudeau “who had the courage to assemble it, to introduce it into parliament and to defend it across the land under the sharp scrutiny of a general election.”

However, his comments didn’t end there. Turner also maintained that “there is nothing in the bill which would condone homosexuality, promote it, endorse it, advertise it, popularize it in any way whatsoever.” That sounds very much like the messenger keeping his distance from the message itself. He went on to suggest that there were areas of private behaviour that even supporters of the bill found “repugnant” and “immoral” even if not criminal, and that acts between people who “suffer under a sexual deviation,” as long as there was no corruption of minors, no force involve and they weren’t performed in public, should not fall under the criminal code. He topped it off by reminding the House that, “We are not for a moment conceding that homosexual acts are in any way to be equated to ordinary, normal acts of intercourse.”

So, there you have it. Bill C-150 was intended to legislate the behaviour of those who oppressed us because of our “criminality.” However, attitudes could not be legislated as evidenced by the tone of those at the top. The context in its entirety, adds new dimensions to our history and sets the scene for the battles, peaceful and violent, that were to be fought over the next couple of decades.

Stay tuned…

 


 
#

Dennis Yeo

Dennis is a former teacher who was born and raised in St. Catharines. He came out as a gay man as an adult, was active in the 2SLGBTQ community in the city where he taught, and returned to St. Catharines when he retired. Dennis will be contributing a periodic blog throughout LGBT History Month (October).

His views do not necessarily represent those of OUTniagara.

Tags: 2SLGBTQ+ History
Previous Story
Day honours ‘coming out’
Next Story
Get OUT and vote!

Related Articles

Young gay organizers propel movement in ’60s

Young gay organizers propel movement in ’60s By Dennis Yeo,...

HERstory: Early lesbian organization created pride and resilience

HERstory: Early lesbian organization created pride and resilience By Dennis...

Become a Member

Stronger together. Join our growing network! Become a member and join a vibrant and diverse community of 2SLGBTQ+ and ally voices.


Become a Member

Recent Posts

  • OUTniagara looking to work with Consultants Friday, 28, Oct
  • Join the OUTniagara Regional Advisory Committee! Wednesday, 21, Sep
  • OUTniagara withdraws support from Canada Summer Games Sunday, 31, Jul
  • OUTniagara Statement regarding Roe vs. Wade overturned Friday, 24, Jun
  • OUTniagara is hiring a Project Assistant! Tuesday, 7, Jun

Categories

2SLGBTQ+ History Community Groups Global News Humans of OUTniagara News Niagara News OUTnews OUT With It Support

Search


OUTniagara supports our local 2SLGBTQ+ community and beyond by amplifying the voices of our community, acting as a public policy advocate and helping to build relationships within the community.

Get In Touch.

12-111 Fourth Avenue, Suite 270
St. Catharines, Ontario L2S 3P5
Email: info@outniagara.ca

With Thanks.

Web hosting and technical support by ALT Technical.

Sign Up for Email Notifications.

[newsletter_form button_label=”Sign Up Now”][newsletter_field name=”email” label=”” placeholder=”Please Enter your Email”][/newsletter_form]

Follow Us:
OUTniagara - Copyright 2018.
SearchPostsLoginCart
Friday, 28, Oct
OUTniagara looking to work with Consultants
Wednesday, 21, Sep
Join the OUTniagara Regional Advisory Committee!
Sunday, 31, Jul
OUTniagara withdraws support from Canada Summer Games
Friday, 24, Jun
OUTniagara Statement regarding Roe vs. Wade overturned
Tuesday, 7, Jun
OUTniagara is hiring a Project Assistant!
Friday, 3, Jun
OUTniagara: Kudos to Niagara Catholic school board for flying progress pride flag

Welcome back,